Government Playing Hide-and-Seek Over New Provinces and Referendum, Says Shahzad Iqbal

ISLAMABAD: Senior journalist Shahzad Iqbal has alleged that the government is playing a game of hide-and-seek over the proposed creation of new provinces and the possibility of a referendum, while key political leaders remain divided over the issue.
Speaking on Geo News programme Report Card, hosted by Alina Farooq Sheikh, Iqbal said Defence Minister Khawaja Asif was so far the most prominent leader from the ruling Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) to have openly discussed the matter.
He recalled that Punjab Assembly Speaker Malik Muhammad Ahmad Khan had also previously suggested that a referendum could be held and the issue might eventually be referred to a constitutional court.
Iqbal said these leaders appeared comfortable discussing the possibility of changes within what they considered a hybrid political system. He added that Khawaja Asif’s position as defence minister could mean he had access to information about the thinking of relevant institutions.
However, he said reports that the entire process could move forward by December had come as a surprise. Besides Khawaja Asif, Mustafa Kamal had also recently indicated that a referendum could take place in December.
The journalist questioned the lack of clarity from the government, saying neither the public nor the media had been properly informed about the proposed developments.
He said that when he asked Khawaja Asif about Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif’s position, the defence minister could not provide a clear answer. The positions of Shehbaz Sharif, Nawaz Sharif and Maryam Nawaz on the matter remained unclear, he added.
Constitutional amendments needed to create new provinces
Discussing the constitutional and administrative implications of creating new provinces, Iqbal said the issue was far more complicated than amending one or two constitutional provisions.
He pointed out that questions relating to water distribution, the allocation of national resources and the National Finance Commission (NFC) Award would all have to be addressed.
According to him, the entire Constitution would require a comprehensive review, making the exercise comparable to the process undertaken for the 18th Constitutional Amendment.
He noted that a 26-member parliamentary committee had been formed during the 18th Amendment process, with even political parties holding only one National Assembly seat given representation to present their views and recommendations.
However, he said no comparable consultation or constitutional exercise was currently taking place regarding the creation of new provinces.
Iqbal also observed that official statements issued after meetings between the president and prime minister contained no reference to the issue. Similarly, no formal details had emerged following Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi’s meeting with the president.
Nevertheless, he said the sequence of political meetings and public statements suggested that discussions were taking place behind the scenes.
Government accused of concealing its position
Criticising the government’s approach, Iqbal said the public deserved transparency rather than what he described as a game of hide-and-seek.
He argued that if the government believed new provinces should not be created, it should openly announce its position.
However, he suggested that the ruling parties were not in a position to openly distance themselves from the matter because of their political circumstances and the events surrounding the formation of the present government.
He predicted that the political parties opposing the proposal might not be able to maintain their resistance for much longer.
Iqbal said the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) had previously appeared determined to oppose the creation of new provinces until the very end. However, Khawaja Asif’s statements about discussions already having taken place and further progress expected by December had raised questions about the PPP’s future position.
He also questioned how the PPP would explain any change in its stance to its supporters, particularly in Sindh.
Sindh united against division, claims journalist
Referring to the political situation in Sindh, Iqbal said he had spoken to two senior provincial political leaders who were also critics of the PTI.
According to him, both maintained that Sindh was united against the creation of new provinces and that no political party in the province supported dividing it.
He said the leaders had made it clear that although they opposed PTI and criticised issues such as corruption and poor governance, they remained united on the question of Sindh’s territorial integrity.
Iqbal compared the unity among political parties on the issue to the solidarity witnessed during wartime.
He added that one proposal being discussed was to seek the public’s opinion through a referendum in Sindh, which could provide political parties with greater justification for their position.
Shehbaz Sharif reportedly on board, but Sharif family divided
Responding to anchor Alina Farooq Sheikh’s question about divisions within the PML-N and the government, Iqbal said he had been informed that Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif was currently on board with the proposal.
However, he said Nawaz Sharif and Punjab Chief Minister Maryam Nawaz had not yet agreed to it.
Regarding the PPP, Iqbal said those involved in the discussions believed that former president Asif Ali Zardari understood the importance of creating new provinces, but the main concern was PPP Chairman Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari, who was reportedly less certain about the proposal.
He argued that the opposition was not necessarily coming from two entire political parties but rather from a handful of individuals belonging to two influential political families.
In conclusion, Iqbal stressed that all political parties must openly express their positions on such an important constitutional matter.
Otherwise, he warned, the situation could create the impression that a decision had already been imposed and political parties were simply being expected to endorse it.





