Judiciary Must Remain Separate from Executive or It Will Become a Slave to the Powerful: Justice Jamal Mandokhail

ISLAMABAD: Supreme Court senior puisne judge Justice Jamal Khan Mandokhail has stressed that the judiciary must remain completely independent of the executive, warning that otherwise it could become subservient to the wishes and interests of powerful groups.
Justice Jamal Mandokhail, who is retiring from his position on Wednesday, expressed these views while addressing a farewell reference held in his honour. He spoke about judicial independence, constitutional supremacy, the powers of Parliament and the role of the executive.
Addressing the gathering, the outgoing Supreme Court judge said only a judiciary that was completely independent of the executive could hold all state institutions accountable without fear and ensure that they operated within the limits of the Constitution and the law.
He said constitutional supremacy and the restoration of moral values were essential for Pakistan’s genuine progress and stability.
According to Justice Mandokhail, only an independent and autonomous judiciary could guarantee the protection of citizens’ fundamental and constitutional rights.
He warned that if the judiciary failed to provide timely and impartial justice to the public, citizens might resort to unlawful means to obtain justice, potentially resulting in anarchy, social disorder and serious unrest.
Parliament Must Protect Judicial Independence
Discussing Parliament’s role in safeguarding judicial independence, Justice Mandokhail said Parliament was the supreme legislative institution representing the people and that the Constitution empowered it to introduce constitutional amendments.
However, he emphasised that constitutional amendments could only be appropriate and acceptable if the fundamental features of the Constitution, particularly judicial independence, remained protected.
He cautioned that Parliament must ensure that no constitutional amendment undermined the independence of the judiciary.
The outgoing Supreme Court judge further clarified that safeguarding judicial independence was not solely the responsibility of judges. Rather, Parliament, the judiciary and the executive shared an equal and collective responsibility to preserve it.
Judges Must Decide Cases on the Basis of Law and Evidence
Justice Jamal Khan Mandokhail said being a judge was not an easy task but involved an extremely sensitive and weighty responsibility.
He explained that a judge’s oath served as a constant reminder while writing and delivering every judgment that decisions must be based on the Constitution, law and evidence rather than personal wishes or preferences.
He stressed that judicial independence was indispensable for ensuring accountability, protecting citizens’ rights and maintaining the rule of law in the country.





