Federal Constitutional Court Says Supreme Court Rulings Not Binding on It

ISLAMABAD: The Federal Constitutional Court has once again clarified that decisions of the Supreme Court are not binding on it.
In an eight-page judgment concerning the Constitutional Court’s powers of review and appeal, Justice Aamer Farooq stated that the Constitutional Court is not bound by Supreme Court judgments. However, such rulings carry persuasive legal value and may be followed where the legal principles established by the Supreme Court are acceptable and consistent with the Constitution and the law.
The court observed that legal principles laid down by the Supreme Court regarding appeals against High Court judgments and orders under Article 199 of the Constitution are not binding on the Constitutional Court.
However, it added that the Constitutional Court may seek guidance from the Supreme Court’s legal principles and judicial precedents.
The judgment further noted that recent trends suggest petitioners and lawyers increasingly treat the review jurisdiction as another opportunity to reopen arguments in a case.
It clarified that a review petition is not meant to provide a fresh hearing of the case. Instead, the bench only examines whether there is any apparent error or defect on the face of the judicial record.
Clarify the court’s legal distinctionTighten repeated references to rulings





