Pakistan

Shehzad Iqbal Accuses PPP of Double Standards on Democracy, Provincial Reforms

ISLAMABAD:Senior journalist Shehzad Iqbal has accused the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) of adopting contradictory positions on the creation of new provinces and democratic principles, questioning whether the party would have raised issues such as alleged electoral rigging, reserved seats, political prisoners and dialogue with the opposition if the debate over new provinces had not emerged.

Speaking on Geo News’ programme *Report Card*, Iqbal said the PPP appeared to support the existing system when it benefited the party but adopted a democratic stance when political pressure shifted towards it.

He said there was merit in criticism that Pakistan’s system had been weakened, adding that the country’s history showed repeated disruptions through martial laws and governor’s rule.

On the creation of new provinces, Iqbal said the Constitution already provided a procedure that should be followed. He stressed the need for broad consultation, pointing out that a legal expert had told him that at least 190 constitutional provisions might need to be reconsidered in the process.

He questioned why discussions about the matter were being kept secret and said the public and relevant stakeholders should be taken into confidence.

The journalist also criticised PPP Chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari’s remarks about the possible creation of new provinces, particularly his warning that such a move could lead to bloodshed.

Iqbal questioned whether such statements reflected a democratic approach, arguing that opponents of new provinces should present constitutional and merit-based arguments rather than create fear among the public.

Recounting an earlier experience from 2019-2020, he said he had asked PPP leader Nisar Khuhro whether the possibility of creating additional provinces in Sindh, including a separate province for Karachi, could be discussed on merit rather than ethnic grounds.

He claimed that the discussion triggered a campaign against him and Geo News, with demands for an apology for even raising the issue.

Addressing Karachi’s law and order situation, Iqbal said the provincial government could not shift responsibility for its shortcomings entirely onto the federal government.

He acknowledged that economic difficulties could contribute to street crime but maintained that maintaining law and order remained the responsibility of the provincial administration.

He also questioned the delay in Karachi’s Safe City project, saying he had been hearing about its implementation for the past 15 years without seeing the promised results.

He pointed out that Safe City projects had been established in several districts of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Punjab, asking why Sindh had failed to make similar progress despite its substantial annual development budget.

Iqbal further questioned the PPP’s political position, noting that the party governed three provinces and held the presidency and Senate chairmanship, yet was now raising questions about alleged rigging in the 2024 general elections.

He also questioned the party’s recent demand for the return of reserved seats to the opposition, claiming that several National Assembly seats had benefited the PPP.

On political prisoners, he asked why the party had not raised similar concerns in previous cases and questioned its response to calls for dialogue between the government and opposition.

Iqbal also referred to the PPP’s earlier position on governor’s rule in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, questioning why the party supported such a measure when the province faced security challenges but was now emphasising democratic principles.

Concluding his remarks, the journalist questioned whether Bilawal Bhutto Zardari would have raised demands concerning electoral transparency, reserved seats, political prisoners and negotiations with the opposition if the issue of creating new provinces had not come to the forefront.

Make the report more conciseUse more neutral news language

Related News

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button
WhatsApp
Get Alert