Minister! Without Information, Without Knowledge

ISLAMABAD – PPP MNA Syeda Shehla Raza has said, “Minister! Without information, without knowledge — does the gentleman not know that the Peoples Party holds a constitutional office and is not part of the cabinet?”
In her reaction on X to Federal Information Minister Atta Tarar’s statement, Syeda Shehla Raza said, “Minister… without information, without knowledge, the gentleman does not know that the Peoples Party holds a constitutional office. It is not part of the cabinet. It supports the government. It is not part of the government. Whatever the Constitution has clarified, there is no ambiguity. There is no referendum on this.”
She said a minister gives the government’s policies, not personal opinion. “Is this not ignorance and open contradiction?”
On the other hand, Federal Information Minister Atta Tarar has said that we cannot impose our agenda on anyone without knowing the people’s will — what is wrong with holding a referendum? He asked whether talking about making small administrative units a cause of conflict or bloodshed is political insight. He asked that if a referendum was ever held undemocratically in the past, can the people now be deprived of their democratic right?
Speaking to the media in reaction to PPP Chairman Bilawal Bhutto’s statement, he said you and all of us have been part of this system for decades, and we cannot today separate ourselves from the system’s weaknesses. He said saying under the guise of politics that we are above accountability is rejected by both the law and the people.
وزیر۔۔۔
بغیر اطلاعات بغیر معلومات۔
موصوف نہیں جانتے کہ۔۔ پیپلز پارٹی آئینی عہدے رکھتی ہے ۔کابینہ کا حصہ نہیں ۔حکومتی حمایت کرتی ہے۔حکومت کا حصہ نہیں۔۔ائین میں جس بات کی وضاحتکر دی گئ ہےاور کوئی ابہام نہیں۔ اس پر ریفرنڈم نہیں ہوتا۔وزیر حکومت کی پالسیز دیتا ہے۔ذاتی رائے نہں ۔کیا یہ جہالت اور کھلا تضاد نہیں۔— Syeda Shehla Raza (@SyedaShehlaRaza) November 17, 2026
He said the NAB reforms were also done by them, and now NAB is being blamed — this is beyond understanding. He said enjoying being in government and simultaneously acting as opposition, holding protocol and offices too — this is both a contradiction and a double standard.
The federal information minister said the real issue we understand behind today’s conversation is the ongoing debate on provinces, which is continuing among the people at full strength. He asked whether people’s mouths should be shut so they do not debate it, and whether people should be stopped from talking about improving governance.
Atta Tarar said this matter will be discussed in parliament and outside parliament, and the people cannot be stopped from exercising their right to talk to them and about their welfare. He said the demand of the democratic and political process is that this debate continue.
He further said the real question is what is the problem in going to the people on this matter? What the people want is not for me and you to decide — the people have to decide this, and no political party should have political reservations about going to the people.
The federal information minister said a referendum is part of the Constitution and seeking public opinion on it is a constitutional and legal procedure. He said the people are the final decision-makers, and good governance is every political party’s manifesto — no party denies this.
He said if the people of Pakistan and the people of Sindh want more provinces, then let them be created, otherwise not. Public representatives come from the people, not the people from representatives — the people are the ultimate decision-makers.
Atta Tarar said instead of making small administrative units a cause of conflict, it is better to look at them constructively. He asked whether talking about bloodshed over it is political insight and maturity. He asked that if a referendum was ever used undemocratically in the past, can the people now be deprived of their democratic right in its name?
He said we cannot impose our agenda on anyone without knowing the will of the people of Sindh and the opinion of all other provinces. He said we are part of the same government — let us sit together and make the best decision in the interest of the people and the country, and this decision should be based on the people’s opinion.





