Pakistan

Experiments of Suppressing Dissent and Criticism Through Harsh Punishments Have Failed: Khawaja Saad Rafique

LAHORE (Daily Qudrat): Senior Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) leader and former federal minister Khawaja Saad Rafique, criticising the tendency of harsh punishments against enforced disappearances, political opponents and law-breaking elements in the country, has said that experiments of crushing dissent, giving long prison sentences to opponents and silencing every voice through force have repeatedly failed; such a course is completely contrary to justice, the Constitution, law and national interest.

In a statement on social media platform X, he said that sometimes individuals engaging in political or social criticism step outside legal and moral limits, abandon moderation and immorally target personalities or state institutions, which is certainly an inappropriate act; however, its solution is by no means to sternly suppress every voice that rises and give extraordinarily harsh punishments. The state must enforce the law, but before punishing any individual, state institutions should seriously assess their own action and its possible negative reaction.


Referring to the case of lawyer and human rights activist Imaan Zainab Mazari and her husband Hadi Ali Chatha, Khawaja Saad Rafique took the position that the incident of removing a traffic barrier or clashing with traffic police was clearly wrong and cannot be defended, but giving Imaan Mazari and her husband a long prison sentence of 10 years by colouring this kind of offence as terrorism is an extremely inappropriate and unjust step.

He said that personally he strongly disagrees with Imaan Zainab Mazari’s manner of speech and many points of her narrative; despite this, the harsh punishments given to her and her husband are absolutely unwarranted. No state can achieve durable development merely on the strength of the severity of the law unless it possesses the elements of open-mindedness, tolerance, prudence and forbearance. Equal application of law enforcement to all classes and avoidance of arbitrary justice are what guarantee the survival of states.

Related News

Back to top button
WhatsApp
Get Alert